Tit for Tat 2.0 program execution
logo
Article written by: Emanuele CassaniHome pubblicazioni  

Tit for Tat Evolution Strategies
Generation Turnament 2.0 program execution


Participants

1) Tit for Tatthis strategy will cooperate if the other did not defect
2) Tit for two Tatthis strategy will cooperate if the other did not defect twice
3) Tit for Tat - Trdthis strategy will cooperate if the other did not defect twice, but every 5 times it will defect
4) Tit for Tat - Rimthis strategy will cooperate if the other did not defect twice, every 5 times it will defect, but it will collaborate if it defected first
5) Always cooperatethis strategy will cooperate in any case
6) Always defectthis strategy will defect in any case
7) Randomthis strategy plays in a ramdom way

Turnament

A=1B=1points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
111515
111818
112121
112424
112727
113030
113333
113636
113939
114242
114545
114848
115151
115454
115757
116060
A=1B=2points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
111515
111818
112121
112424
112727
113030
113333
113636
113939
114242
114545
114848
115151
115454
115757
116060
A=1B=3points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
101217
011717
101722
012222
102227
002328
002429
002530
002631
002732
002833
002934
003035
003136
003237
003338
A=1B=4points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
101217
011717
112020
112323
112626
102631
013131
113434
113737
114040
104045
014545
114848
115151
115454
105459
A=1B=5points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
111515
111818
112121
112424
112727
113030
113333
113636
113939
114242
114545
114848
115151
115454
115757
116060
A=1B=6points
A
points
B
1005
0016
0027
0038
0049
00510
00611
00712
00813
00914
001015
001116
001217
001318
001419
001520
001621
001722
001823
001924
A=1B=7points
A
points
B
1005
0016
0027
0038
0049
00510
00611
011111
101116
011616
111919
101924
012424
102429
002530
002631
013131
113434
113737
114040
A=2B=2points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
111515
111818
112121
112424
112727
113030
113333
113636
113939
114242
114545
114848
115151
115454
115757
116060
A=2B=3points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
101217
111520
111823
112126
112429
102434
112737
113040
113343
113646
103651
113954
114257
114560
114863
104868
A=2B=4points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
101217
111520
111823
112126
112429
102434
112737
113040
113343
113646
103651
113954
114257
114560
114863
104868
A=2B=5points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
111515
111818
112121
112424
112727
113030
113333
113636
113939
114242
114545
114848
115151
115454
115757
116060
A=2B=6points
A
points
B
1005
10010
00111
00212
00313
00414
00515
00616
00717
00818
00919
001020
001121
001222
001323
001424
001525
001626
001727
001828
A=2B=7points
A
points
B
1133
1038
11611
11914
111217
111520
111823
112126
102131
112434
102439
112742
113045
103050
103055
003156
003257
003358
013858
103863
A=3B=3points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
001313
001414
001515
001616
001717
001818
001919
002020
002121
002222
002323
002424
002525
002626
002727
002828
A=3B=4points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
001313
001414
011914
112217
112520
002621
002722
013222
113525
113828
003929
004030
014530
114833
115136
005237
A=3B=5points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
011712
112015
112318
112621
112924
013424
113727
114030
114333
114636
015136
115439
115742
116045
116348
016848
A=3B=6points
A
points
B
1005
0016
0027
0038
0049
00510
00611
00712
00813
00914
001015
001116
001217
001318
001419
001520
001621
001722
001823
001924
A=3B=7points
A
points
B
1005
0016
0166
10611
011111
101116
011616
111919
101924
012424
102429
012929
113232
113535
003636
003737
014237
104242
014742
004843
A=4B=4points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
001313
001414
111717
112020
112323
002424
002525
112828
113131
113434
003535
003636
113939
114242
114545
004646
A=4B=5points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
011712
112015
112318
112621
112924
013424
113727
114030
114333
114636
015136
115439
115742
116045
116348
016848
A=4B=6points
A
points
B
1005
0016
0027
10212
00313
00414
10419
10424
00525
00626
10631
10636
00737
00838
00939
10944
10949
001050
001151
001252
A=4B=7points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
001313
011813
112116
102121
002222
012722
113025
103030
013530
113833
014333
114636
114939
115242
115545
005646
A=5B=5points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
111515
111818
112121
112424
112727
113030
113333
113636
113939
114242
114545
114848
115151
115454
115757
116060
A=5B=6points
A
points
B
1005
10010
10015
10020
10025
10030
10035
10040
10045
10050
10055
10060
10065
10070
10075
10080
10085
10090
10095
100100
A=5B=7points
A
points
B
1005
1138
11611
11914
10919
10924
10929
10934
10939
10944
10949
111252
111555
101560
111863
112166
112469
112772
113075
113378
A=6B=6points
A
points
B
0011
0022
0033
0044
0055
0066
0077
0088
0099
001010
001111
001212
001313
001414
001515
001616
001717
001818
001919
002020
A=6B=7points
A
points
B
0150
0061
01111
00122
01172
01222
01272
01322
00333
01383
01433
01483
01533
01583
01633
00644
01694
01744
01794
00805
A=7B=7points
A
points
B
1005
10010
01510
00611
11914
011414
001515
001616
012116
002217
012717
102722
102727
002828
013328
113631
014131
104136
004237
114540

Classification

Classification after 28 games
1) Tit for TatFinal score=386
2) Tit for two TatFinal score=392
3) Tit for Tat - TrdFinal score=349
4) Tit for Tat - RimFinal score=392
5) Always cooperateFinal score=369
6) Always defectFinal score=348
7) RandomFinal score=360

Mutuants

90% is the percentage of the score if both the opponents was always cooperating that is necessary for the strategy to suvive. Minimum score =378
Strategy number: 3 the character number 1 changes da=G a=A
Strategy number: 5 the character number 4 changes da=T a=A
Strategy number: 6 the character number 7 changes da=C a=T
Strategy number: 7 the character number 5 changes da=C a=T
Mutants of generation number 2
1) Tit for TatDNA=AAAAGAAAAATAUAG
2) Tit for two TatDNA=AATGATATTTTAUAG
3) 1 mutant of Tit for Tat - TrdDNA=ACCTACAATGACUAG
4) Tit for Tat - RimDNA=GTGGCGATTGTCUAG
5) 1 mutant of Always cooperateDNA=AAATACACATTGUAG
6) 1 mutant of Always defectDNA=TGTTACTCAGAAUAG
7) 1 mutant of RandomDNA=GCCTACGCACCAUAG
A=1B=1points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
111515
111818
112121
112424
112727
113030
113333
113636
113939
114242
114545
114848
115151
115454
115757
116060
A=1B=2points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
111515
111818
112121
112424
112727
113030
113333
113636
113939
114242
114545
114848
115151
115454
115757
116060
A=1B=3points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
111515
111818
112121
112424
112727
113030
113333
113636
113939
114242
114545
114848
115151
115454
115757
116060
A=1B=4points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
101217
011717
112020
112323
112626
102631
013131
113434
113737
114040
104045
014545
114848
115151
115454
105459
A=1B=5points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
111515
111818
112121
112424
112727
113030
113333
113636
113939
114242
114545
114848
115151
115454
115757
116060
A=1B=6points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
111515
111818
112121
112424
112727
113030
113333
113636
113939
114242
114545
114848
115151
115454
115757
116060
A=1B=7points
A
points
B
1005
0155
10510
011010
101015
011515
101520
012020
102025
012525
102530
013030
103035
013535
103540
014040
104045
014545
104550
015050
A=2B=2points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
111515
111818
112121
112424
112727
113030
113333
113636
113939
114242
114545
114848
115151
115454
115757
116060
A=2B=3points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
111515
111818
112121
112424
112727
113030
113333
113636
113939
114242
114545
114848
115151
115454
115757
116060
A=2B=4points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
101217
111520
111823
112126
112429
102434
112737
113040
113343
113646
103651
113954
114257
114560
114863
104868
A=2B=5points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
111515
111818
112121
112424
112727
113030
113333
113636
113939
114242
114545
114848
115151
115454
115757
116060
A=2B=6points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
111515
111818
112121
112424
112727
113030
113333
113636
113939
114242
114545
114848
115151
115454
115757
116060
A=2B=7points
A
points
B
1005
1138
11611
11914
111217
111520
111823
112126
112429
112732
113035
113338
113641
113944
114247
114550
114853
115156
115459
115762
A=3B=3points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
001313
111616
111919
112222
112525
002626
112929
113232
113535
113838
003939
114242
114545
114848
115151
005252
A=3B=4points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
001313
101318
011818
112121
112424
002525
102530
013030
113333
113636
003737
103742
014242
114545
114848
004949
A=3B=5points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
001313
111616
111919
112222
112525
002626
112929
113232
113535
113838
003939
114242
114545
114848
115151
005252
A=3B=6points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
001313
111616
111919
112222
112525
002626
112929
113232
113535
113838
003939
114242
114545
114848
115151
005252
A=3B=7points
A
points
B
1005
1138
11611
11914
001015
111318
111621
111924
112227
002328
112631
112934
113237
113540
003641
113944
114247
114550
114853
004954
A=4B=4points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
001313
001414
111717
112020
112323
002424
002525
112828
113131
113434
003535
003636
113939
114242
114545
004646
A=4B=5points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
001313
011813
112116
112419
112722
002823
013323
113626
113929
114232
004333
014833
115136
115439
115742
005843
A=4B=6points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
001313
011813
112116
112419
112722
002823
013323
113626
113929
114232
004333
014833
115136
115439
115742
005843
A=4B=7points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
001313
011813
112116
112419
112722
002823
013323
113626
113929
114232
004333
014833
115136
115439
115742
005843
A=5B=5points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
111515
111818
112121
112424
112727
113030
113333
113636
113939
114242
114545
114848
115151
115454
115757
116060
A=5B=6points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
111515
111818
112121
112424
112727
113030
113333
113636
113939
114242
114545
114848
115151
115454
115757
116060
A=5B=7points
A
points
B
1005
1138
11611
11914
111217
111520
111823
112126
112429
112732
113035
113338
113641
113944
114247
114550
114853
115156
115459
115762
A=6B=6points
A
points
B
1133
0044
0055
0066
0077
0088
0099
001010
001111
001212
001313
001414
001515
001616
001717
001818
001919
002020
002121
002222
A=6B=7points
A
points
B
1133
0044
0055
0066
0077
0088
0099
001010
001111
001212
001313
001414
001515
001616
001717
001818
001919
002020
002121
002222
A=7B=7points
A
points
B
0011
0161
1194
00105
01155
101510
001611
012111
012611
002712
102717
002818
002919
102924
113227
013727
003828
103833
114136
114439
Classification after 56 games
1) Tit for TatFinal score=464
2) Tit for two TatFinal score=465
3) 1 mutant of Tit for Tat - TrdFinal score=426
4) Tit for Tat - RimFinal score=442
5) 1 mutant of Always cooperateFinal score=452
6) 1 mutant of Always defectFinal score=341
7) 1 mutant of RandomFinal score=376

Strategy number: 6 the character number 3 changes da=T a=G
Strategy number: 7 the character number 3 changes da=C a=T
Mutants of generation number 3
1) Tit for TatDNA=AAAAGAAAAATAUAG
2) Tit for two TatDNA=AATGATATTTTAUAG
3) 1 mutant of Tit for Tat - TrdDNA=ACCTACAATGACUAG
4) Tit for Tat - RimDNA=GTGGCGATTGTCUAG
5) 1 mutant of Always cooperateDNA=AAATACACATTGUAG
6) 2 mutant of Always defectDNA=TGGTACTCAGAAUAG
7) 2 mutant of RandomDNA=GCTTACGCACCAUAG
A=1B=1points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
111515
111818
112121
112424
112727
113030
113333
113636
113939
114242
114545
114848
115151
115454
115757
116060
A=1B=2points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
111515
111818
112121
112424
112727
113030
113333
113636
113939
114242
114545
114848
115151
115454
115757
116060
A=1B=3points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
111515
111818
112121
112424
112727
113030
113333
113636
113939
114242
114545
114848
115151
115454
115757
116060
A=1B=4points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
101217
011717
112020
112323
112626
102631
013131
113434
113737
114040
104045
014545
114848
115151
115454
105459
A=1B=5points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
111515
111818
112121
112424
112727
113030
113333
113636
113939
114242
114545
114848
115151
115454
115757
116060
A=1B=6points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
111515
111818
112121
112424
112727
113030
113333
113636
113939
114242
114545
114848
115151
115454
115757
116060
A=1B=7points
A
points
B
1005
0155
10510
011010
101015
011515
101520
012020
102025
012525
102530
013030
103035
013535
103540
014040
104045
014545
104550
015050
A=2B=2points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
111515
111818
112121
112424
112727
113030
113333
113636
113939
114242
114545
114848
115151
115454
115757
116060
A=2B=3points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
111515
111818
112121
112424
112727
113030
113333
113636
113939
114242
114545
114848
115151
115454
115757
116060
A=2B=4points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
101217
111520
111823
112126
112429
102434
112737
113040
113343
113646
103651
113954
114257
114560
114863
104868
A=2B=5points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
111515
111818
112121
112424
112727
113030
113333
113636
113939
114242
114545
114848
115151
115454
115757
116060
A=2B=6points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
111515
111818
112121
112424
112727
113030
113333
113636
113939
114242
114545
114848
115151
115454
115757
116060
A=2B=7points
A
points
B
1005
1138
11611
11914
111217
111520
111823
112126
112429
112732
113035
113338
113641
113944
114247
114550
114853
115156
115459
115762
A=3B=3points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
001313
111616
111919
112222
112525
002626
112929
113232
113535
113838
003939
114242
114545
114848
115151
005252
A=3B=4points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
001313
101318
011818
112121
112424
002525
102530
013030
113333
113636
003737
103742
014242
114545
114848
004949
A=3B=5points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
001313
111616
111919
112222
112525
002626
112929
113232
113535
113838
003939
114242
114545
114848
115151
005252
A=3B=6points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
001313
111616
111919
112222
112525
002626
112929
113232
113535
113838
003939
114242
114545
114848
115151
005252
A=3B=7points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
001313
111616
111919
112222
112525
002626
112929
113232
113535
113838
003939
114242
114545
114848
115151
005252
A=4B=4points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
001313
001414
111717
112020
112323
002424
002525
112828
113131
113434
003535
003636
113939
114242
114545
004646
A=4B=5points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
001313
011813
112116
112419
112722
002823
013323
113626
113929
114232
004333
014833
115136
115439
115742
005843
A=4B=6points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
001313
011813
112116
112419
112722
002823
013323
113626
113929
114232
004333
014833
115136
115439
115742
005843
A=4B=7points
A
points
B
1005
0155
1188
111111
001212
011712
112015
112318
112621
002722
013222
113525
113828
114131
004232
014732
115035
115338
115641
005742
A=5B=5points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
111515
111818
112121
112424
112727
113030
113333
113636
113939
114242
114545
114848
115151
115454
115757
116060
A=5B=6points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
111515
111818
112121
112424
112727
113030
113333
113636
113939
114242
114545
114848
115151
115454
115757
116060
A=5B=7points
A
points
B
1005
1138
11611
11914
111217
111520
111823
112126
112429
112732
113035
113338
113641
113944
114247
114550
114853
115156
115459
115762
A=6B=6points
A
points
B
1133
0044
0055
0066
0077
0088
0099
001010
001111
001212
001313
001414
001515
001616
001717
001818
001919
002020
002121
002222
A=6B=7points
A
points
B
1005
0016
0027
0038
0049
00510
00611
00712
00813
00914
001015
001116
001217
001318
001419
001520
001621
001722
001823
001924
A=7B=7points
A
points
B
1133
0044
0055
01105
01155
101510
012010
002111
112414
012914
102919
102924
113227
113530
003631
113934
014434
004535
114838
104843
Classification after 84 games
1) Tit for TatFinal score=464
2) Tit for two TatFinal score=465
3) 1 mutant of Tit for Tat - TrdFinal score=429
4) Tit for Tat - RimFinal score=441
5) 1 mutant of Always cooperateFinal score=452
6) 2 mutant of Always defectFinal score=338
7) 2 mutant of RandomFinal score=383

Strategy number: 6 the character number 3 changes da=G a=A
Mutants of generation number 4
1) Tit for TatDNA=AAAAGAAAAATAUAG
2) Tit for two TatDNA=AATGATATTTTAUAG
3) 1 mutant of Tit for Tat - TrdDNA=ACCTACAATGACUAG
4) Tit for Tat - RimDNA=GTGGCGATTGTCUAG
5) 1 mutant of Always cooperateDNA=AAATACACATTGUAG
6) 3 mutant of Always defectDNA=TGATACTCAGAAUAG
7) 2 mutant of RandomDNA=GCTTACGCACCAUAG
A=1B=1points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
111515
111818
112121
112424
112727
113030
113333
113636
113939
114242
114545
114848
115151
115454
115757
116060
A=1B=2points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
111515
111818
112121
112424
112727
113030
113333
113636
113939
114242
114545
114848
115151
115454
115757
116060
A=1B=3points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
111515
111818
112121
112424
112727
113030
113333
113636
113939
114242
114545
114848
115151
115454
115757
116060
A=1B=4points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
101217
011717
112020
112323
112626
102631
013131
113434
113737
114040
104045
014545
114848
115151
115454
105459
A=1B=5points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
111515
111818
112121
112424
112727
113030
113333
113636
113939
114242
114545
114848
115151
115454
115757
116060
A=1B=6points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
111515
111818
112121
112424
112727
113030
113333
113636
113939
114242
114545
114848
115151
115454
115757
116060
A=1B=7points
A
points
B
1005
0155
10510
011010
101015
011515
101520
012020
102025
012525
102530
013030
103035
013535
103540
014040
104045
014545
104550
015050
A=2B=2points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
111515
111818
112121
112424
112727
113030
113333
113636
113939
114242
114545
114848
115151
115454
115757
116060
A=2B=3points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
111515
111818
112121
112424
112727
113030
113333
113636
113939
114242
114545
114848
115151
115454
115757
116060
A=2B=4points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
101217
111520
111823
112126
112429
102434
112737
113040
113343
113646
103651
113954
114257
114560
114863
104868
A=2B=5points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
111515
111818
112121
112424
112727
113030
113333
113636
113939
114242
114545
114848
115151
115454
115757
116060
A=2B=6points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
111515
111818
112121
112424
112727
113030
113333
113636
113939
114242
114545
114848
115151
115454
115757
116060
A=2B=7points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
111515
111818
112121
112424
112727
113030
113333
113636
113939
114242
114545
114848
115151
115454
115757
116060
A=3B=3points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
001313
111616
111919
112222
112525
002626
112929
113232
113535
113838
003939
114242
114545
114848
115151
005252
A=3B=4points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
001313
101318
011818
112121
112424
002525
102530
013030
113333
113636
003737
103742
014242
114545
114848
004949
A=3B=5points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
001313
111616
111919
112222
112525
002626
112929
113232
113535
113838
003939
114242
114545
114848
115151
005252
A=3B=6points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
001313
111616
111919
112222
112525
002626
112929
113232
113535
113838
003939
114242
114545
114848
115151
005252
A=3B=7points
A
points
B
1005
1138
11611
11914
001015
111318
111621
111924
112227
002328
112631
112934
113237
113540
003641
113944
114247
114550
114853
004954
A=4B=4points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
001313
001414
111717
112020
112323
002424
002525
112828
113131
113434
003535
003636
113939
114242
114545
004646
A=4B=5points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
001313
011813
112116
112419
112722
002823
013323
113626
113929
114232
004333
014833
115136
115439
115742
005843
A=4B=6points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
001313
011813
112116
112419
112722
002823
013323
113626
113929
114232
004333
014833
115136
115439
115742
005843
A=4B=7points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
001313
011813
112116
112419
112722
002823
013323
113626
113929
114232
004333
014833
115136
115439
115742
005843
A=5B=5points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
111515
111818
112121
112424
112727
113030
113333
113636
113939
114242
114545
114848
115151
115454
115757
116060
A=5B=6points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
111515
111818
112121
112424
112727
113030
113333
113636
113939
114242
114545
114848
115151
115454
115757
116060
A=5B=7points
A
points
B
1005
1138
11611
11914
111217
111520
111823
112126
112429
112732
113035
113338
113641
113944
114247
114550
114853
115156
115459
115762
A=6B=6points
A
points
B
1133
0044
0055
0066
0077
0088
0099
001010
001111
001212
001313
001414
001515
001616
001717
001818
001919
002020
002121
002222
A=6B=7points
A
points
B
1005
0016
0027
0038
0049
00510
00611
00712
00813
00914
001015
001116
001217
001318
001419
001520
001621
001722
001823
001924
A=7B=7points
A
points
B
0011
1016
1149
0199
01149
101414
111717
012217
102222
112525
112828
002929
102934
013434
113737
114040
114343
004444
014944
015444
Classification after 112 games
1) Tit for TatFinal score=464
2) Tit for two TatFinal score=468
3) 1 mutant of Tit for Tat - TrdFinal score=426
4) Tit for Tat - RimFinal score=442
5) 1 mutant of Always cooperateFinal score=452
6) 3 mutant of Always defectFinal score=338
7) 2 mutant of RandomFinal score=391

Strategy number: 6 the character number 9 changes da=A a=T
Mutants of generation number 5
1) Tit for TatDNA=AAAAGAAAAATAUAG
2) Tit for two TatDNA=AATGATATTTTAUAG
3) 1 mutant of Tit for Tat - TrdDNA=ACCTACAATGACUAG
4) Tit for Tat - RimDNA=GTGGCGATTGTCUAG
5) 1 mutant of Always cooperateDNA=AAATACACATTGUAG
6) 4 mutant of Always defectDNA=TGATACTCTGAAUAG
7) 2 mutant of RandomDNA=GCTTACGCACCAUAG
A=1B=1points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
111515
111818
112121
112424
112727
113030
113333
113636
113939
114242
114545
114848
115151
115454
115757
116060
A=1B=2points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
111515
111818
112121
112424
112727
113030
113333
113636
113939
114242
114545
114848
115151
115454
115757
116060
A=1B=3points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
111515
111818
112121
112424
112727
113030
113333
113636
113939
114242
114545
114848
115151
115454
115757
116060
A=1B=4points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
101217
011717
112020
112323
112626
102631
013131
113434
113737
114040
104045
014545
114848
115151
115454
105459
A=1B=5points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
111515
111818
112121
112424
112727
113030
113333
113636
113939
114242
114545
114848
115151
115454
115757
116060
A=1B=6points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
111515
111818
112121
112424
112727
113030
113333
113636
113939
114242
114545
114848
115151
115454
115757
116060
A=1B=7points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
111515
111818
112121
112424
112727
113030
113333
113636
113939
114242
114545
114848
115151
115454
115757
116060
A=2B=2points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
111515
111818
112121
112424
112727
113030
113333
113636
113939
114242
114545
114848
115151
115454
115757
116060
A=2B=3points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
111515
111818
112121
112424
112727
113030
113333
113636
113939
114242
114545
114848
115151
115454
115757
116060
A=2B=4points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
101217
111520
111823
112126
112429
102434
112737
113040
113343
113646
103651
113954
114257
114560
114863
104868
A=2B=5points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
111515
111818
112121
112424
112727
113030
113333
113636
113939
114242
114545
114848
115151
115454
115757
116060
A=2B=6points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
111515
111818
112121
112424
112727
113030
113333
113636
113939
114242
114545
114848
115151
115454
115757
116060
A=2B=7points
A
points
B
1005
1138
11611
11914
111217
111520
111823
112126
112429
112732
113035
113338
113641
113944
114247
114550
114853
115156
115459
115762
A=3B=3points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
001313
111616
111919
112222
112525
002626
112929
113232
113535
113838
003939
114242
114545
114848
115151
005252
A=3B=4points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
001313
101318
011818
112121
112424
002525
102530
013030
113333
113636
003737
103742
014242
114545
114848
004949
A=3B=5points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
001313
111616
111919
112222
112525
002626
112929
113232
113535
113838
003939
114242
114545
114848
115151
005252
A=3B=6points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
001313
111616
111919
112222
112525
002626
112929
113232
113535
113838
003939
114242
114545
114848
115151
005252
A=3B=7points
A
points
B
1005
1138
11611
11914
001015
111318
111621
111924
112227
002328
112631
112934
113237
113540
003641
113944
114247
114550
114853
004954
A=4B=4points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
001313
001414
111717
112020
112323
002424
002525
112828
113131
113434
003535
003636
113939
114242
114545
004646
A=4B=5points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
001313
011813
112116
112419
112722
002823
013323
113626
113929
114232
004333
014833
115136
115439
115742
005843
A=4B=6points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
001313
011813
112116
112419
112722
002823
013323
113626
113929
114232
004333
014833
115136
115439
115742
005843
A=4B=7points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
001313
011813
112116
112419
112722
002823
013323
113626
113929
114232
004333
014833
115136
115439
115742
005843
A=5B=5points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
111515
111818
112121
112424
112727
113030
113333
113636
113939
114242
114545
114848
115151
115454
115757
116060
A=5B=6points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
111515
111818
112121
112424
112727
113030
113333
113636
113939
114242
114545
114848
115151
115454
115757
116060
A=5B=7points
A
points
B
1005
1138
11611
11914
111217
111520
111823
112126
112429
112732
113035
113338
113641
113944
114247
114550
114853
115156
115459
115762
A=6B=6points
A
points
B
1133
0044
0055
0066
0077
0088
0099
001010
001111
001212
001313
001414
001515
001616
001717
001818
001919
002020
002121
002222
A=6B=7points
A
points
B
1133
0044
0055
0066
0077
0088
0099
001010
001111
001212
001313
001414
001515
001616
001717
001818
001919
002020
002121
002222
A=7B=7points
A
points
B
0011
1144
1049
11712
00813
00914
001015
111318
011818
101823
001924
112227
112530
002631
013131
013631
014131
104136
004237
104242
Classification after 140 games
1) Tit for TatFinal score=474
2) Tit for two TatFinal score=465
3) 1 mutant of Tit for Tat - TrdFinal score=426
4) Tit for Tat - RimFinal score=442
5) 1 mutant of Always cooperateFinal score=452
6) 4 mutant of Always defectFinal score=341
7) 2 mutant of RandomFinal score=387

Strategy number: 6 the character number 5 changes da=A a=G
Mutants of generation number 6
1) Tit for TatDNA=AAAAGAAAAATAUAG
2) Tit for two TatDNA=AATGATATTTTAUAG
3) 1 mutant of Tit for Tat - TrdDNA=ACCTACAATGACUAG
4) Tit for Tat - RimDNA=GTGGCGATTGTCUAG
5) 1 mutant of Always cooperateDNA=AAATACACATTGUAG
6) 5 mutant of Always defectDNA=TGATACTCTGAAUAG
7) 2 mutant of RandomDNA=GCTTACGCACCAUAG
A=1B=1points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
111515
111818
112121
112424
112727
113030
113333
113636
113939
114242
114545
114848
115151
115454
115757
116060
A=1B=2points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
111515
111818
112121
112424
112727
113030
113333
113636
113939
114242
114545
114848
115151
115454
115757
116060
A=1B=3points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
111515
111818
112121
112424
112727
113030
113333
113636
113939
114242
114545
114848
115151
115454
115757
116060
A=1B=4points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
101217
011717
112020
112323
112626
102631
013131
113434
113737
114040
104045
014545
114848
115151
115454
105459
A=1B=5points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
111515
111818
112121
112424
112727
113030
113333
113636
113939
114242
114545
114848
115151
115454
115757
116060
A=1B=6points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
111515
111818
112121
112424
112727
113030
113333
113636
113939
114242
114545
114848
115151
115454
115757
116060
A=1B=7points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
111515
111818
112121
112424
112727
113030
113333
113636
113939
114242
114545
114848
115151
115454
115757
116060
A=2B=2points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
111515
111818
112121
112424
112727
113030
113333
113636
113939
114242
114545
114848
115151
115454
115757
116060
A=2B=3points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
111515
111818
112121
112424
112727
113030
113333
113636
113939
114242
114545
114848
115151
115454
115757
116060
A=2B=4points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
101217
111520
111823
112126
112429
102434
112737
113040
113343
113646
103651
113954
114257
114560
114863
104868
A=2B=5points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
111515
111818
112121
112424
112727
113030
113333
113636
113939
114242
114545
114848
115151
115454
115757
116060
A=2B=6points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
111515
111818
112121
112424
112727
113030
113333
113636
113939
114242
114545
114848
115151
115454
115757
116060
A=2B=7points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
111515
111818
112121
112424
112727
113030
113333
113636
113939
114242
114545
114848
115151
115454
115757
116060
A=3B=3points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
001313
111616
111919
112222
112525
002626
112929
113232
113535
113838
003939
114242
114545
114848
115151
005252
A=3B=4points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
001313
101318
011818
112121
112424
002525
102530
013030
113333
113636
003737
103742
014242
114545
114848
004949
A=3B=5points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
001313
111616
111919
112222
112525
002626
112929
113232
113535
113838
003939
114242
114545
114848
115151
005252
A=3B=6points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
001313
111616
111919
112222
112525
002626
112929
113232
113535
113838
003939
114242
114545
114848
115151
005252
A=3B=7points
A
points
B
1005
1138
11611
11914
001015
111318
111621
111924
112227
002328
112631
112934
113237
113540
003641
113944
114247
114550
114853
004954
A=4B=4points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
001313
001414
111717
112020
112323
002424
002525
112828
113131
113434
003535
003636
113939
114242
114545
004646
A=4B=5points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
001313
011813
112116
112419
112722
002823
013323
113626
113929
114232
004333
014833
115136
115439
115742
005843
A=4B=6points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
001313
011813
112116
112419
112722
002823
013323
113626
113929
114232
004333
014833
115136
115439
115742
005843
A=4B=7points
A
points
B
1005
0155
1188
111111
001212
011712
112015
112318
112621
002722
013222
113525
113828
114131
004232
014732
115035
115338
115641
005742
A=5B=5points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
111515
111818
112121
112424
112727
113030
113333
113636
113939
114242
114545
114848
115151
115454
115757
116060
A=5B=6points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
111515
111818
112121
112424
112727
113030
113333
113636
113939
114242
114545
114848
115151
115454
115757
116060
A=5B=7points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
111515
111818
112121
112424
112727
113030
113333
113636
113939
114242
114545
114848
115151
115454
115757
116060
A=6B=6points
A
points
B
1133
0044
0055
0066
0077
0088
0099
001010
001111
001212
001313
001414
001515
001616
001717
001818
001919
002020
002121
002222
A=6B=7points
A
points
B
1133
0044
0055
0066
0077
0088
0099
001010
001111
001212
001313
001414
001515
001616
001717
001818
001919
002020
002121
002222
A=7B=7points
A
points
B
0011
1144
0055
0066
1199
10914
10919
001020
011520
012020
112323
012823
002924
003025
113328
103333
103338
113641
014141
014641
Classification after 168 games
1) Tit for TatFinal score=474
2) Tit for two TatFinal score=468
3) 1 mutant of Tit for Tat - TrdFinal score=426
4) Tit for Tat - RimFinal score=441
5) 1 mutant of Always cooperateFinal score=455
6) 5 mutant of Always defectFinal score=341
7) 2 mutant of RandomFinal score=385

Strategy number: 6 the character number 2 changes da=G a=A
Mutants of generation number 7
1) Tit for TatDNA=AAAAGAAAAATAUAG
2) Tit for two TatDNA=AATGATATTTTAUAG
3) 1 mutant of Tit for Tat - TrdDNA=ACCTACAATGACUAG
4) Tit for Tat - RimDNA=GTGGCGATTGTCUAG
5) 1 mutant of Always cooperateDNA=AAATACACATTGUAG
6) 6 mutant of Always defectDNA=TAATACTCTGAAUAG
7) 2 mutant of RandomDNA=GCTTACGCACCAUAG
A=1B=1points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
111515
111818
112121
112424
112727
113030
113333
113636
113939
114242
114545
114848
115151
115454
115757
116060
A=1B=2points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
111515
111818
112121
112424
112727
113030
113333
113636
113939
114242
114545
114848
115151
115454
115757
116060
A=1B=3points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
111515
111818
112121
112424
112727
113030
113333
113636
113939
114242
114545
114848
115151
115454
115757
116060
A=1B=4points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
101217
011717
112020
112323
112626
102631
013131
113434
113737
114040
104045
014545
114848
115151
115454
105459
A=1B=5points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
111515
111818
112121
112424
112727
113030
113333
113636
113939
114242
114545
114848
115151
115454
115757
116060
A=1B=6points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
111515
111818
112121
112424
112727
113030
113333
113636
113939
114242
114545
114848
115151
115454
115757
116060
A=1B=7points
A
points
B
1005
0155
10510
011010
101015
011515
101520
012020
102025
012525
102530
013030
103035
013535
103540
014040
104045
014545
104550
015050
A=2B=2points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
111515
111818
112121
112424
112727
113030
113333
113636
113939
114242
114545
114848
115151
115454
115757
116060
A=2B=3points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
111515
111818
112121
112424
112727
113030
113333
113636
113939
114242
114545
114848
115151
115454
115757
116060
A=2B=4points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
101217
111520
111823
112126
112429
102434
112737
113040
113343
113646
103651
113954
114257
114560
114863
104868
A=2B=5points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
111515
111818
112121
112424
112727
113030
113333
113636
113939
114242
114545
114848
115151
115454
115757
116060
A=2B=6points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
111515
111818
112121
112424
112727
113030
113333
113636
113939
114242
114545
114848
115151
115454
115757
116060
A=2B=7points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
111515
111818
112121
112424
112727
113030
113333
113636
113939
114242
114545
114848
115151
115454
115757
116060
A=3B=3points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
001313
111616
111919
112222
112525
002626
112929
113232
113535
113838
003939
114242
114545
114848
115151
005252
A=3B=4points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
001313
101318
011818
112121
112424
002525
102530
013030
113333
113636
003737
103742
014242
114545
114848
004949
A=3B=5points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
001313
111616
111919
112222
112525
002626
112929
113232
113535
113838
003939
114242
114545
114848
115151
005252
A=3B=6points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
001313
111616
111919
112222
112525
002626
112929
113232
113535
113838
003939
114242
114545
114848
115151
005252
A=3B=7points
A
points
B
1005
1138
11611
11914
001015
111318
111621
111924
112227
002328
112631
112934
113237
113540
003641
113944
114247
114550
114853
004954
A=4B=4points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
001313
001414
111717
112020
112323
002424
002525
112828
113131
113434
003535
003636
113939
114242
114545
004646
A=4B=5points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
001313
011813
112116
112419
112722
002823
013323
113626
113929
114232
004333
014833
115136
115439
115742
005843
A=4B=6points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
001313
011813
112116
112419
112722
002823
013323
113626
113929
114232
004333
014833
115136
115439
115742
005843
A=4B=7points
A
points
B
1005
0155
1188
111111
001212
011712
112015
112318
112621
002722
013222
113525
113828
114131
004232
014732
115035
115338
115641
005742
A=5B=5points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
111515
111818
112121
112424
112727
113030
113333
113636
113939
114242
114545
114848
115151
115454
115757
116060
A=5B=6points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
111515
111818
112121
112424
112727
113030
113333
113636
113939
114242
114545
114848
115151
115454
115757
116060
A=5B=7points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
111515
111818
112121
112424
112727
113030
113333
113636
113939
114242
114545
114848
115151
115454
115757
116060
A=6B=6points
A
points
B
1133
0044
0055
0066
0077
0088
0099
001010
001111
001212
001313
001414
001515
001616
001717
001818
001919
002020
002121
002222
A=6B=7points
A
points
B
1133
0044
0055
0066
0077
0088
0099
001010
001111
001212
001313
001414
001515
001616
001717
001818
001919
002020
002121
002222
A=7B=7points
A
points
B
0011
1144
1049
10414
00515
00616
10621
11924
011424
011924
012424
102429
002530
002631
002732
002833
013333
003434
113737
114040
Classification after 196 games
1) Tit for TatFinal score=464
2) Tit for two TatFinal score=468
3) 1 mutant of Tit for Tat - TrdFinal score=426
4) Tit for Tat - RimFinal score=441
5) 1 mutant of Always cooperateFinal score=455
6) 6 mutant of Always defectFinal score=341
7) 2 mutant of RandomFinal score=368

Strategy number: 6 the character number 6 changes da=C a=T
Strategy number: 7 the character number 4 changes da=T a=A
Mutants of generation number 8
1) Tit for TatDNA=AAAAGAAAAATAUAG
2) Tit for two TatDNA=AATGATATTTTAUAG
3) 1 mutant of Tit for Tat - TrdDNA=ACCTACAATGACUAG
4) Tit for Tat - RimDNA=GTGGCGATTGTCUAG
5) 1 mutant of Always cooperateDNA=AAATACACATTGUAG
6) 7 mutant of Always defectDNA=TAATACTCTGAAUAG
7) 3 mutant of RandomDNA=GCTTACGCACCAUAG
A=1B=1points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
111515
111818
112121
112424
112727
113030
113333
113636
113939
114242
114545
114848
115151
115454
115757
116060
A=1B=2points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
111515
111818
112121
112424
112727
113030
113333
113636
113939
114242
114545
114848
115151
115454
115757
116060
A=1B=3points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
111515
111818
112121
112424
112727
113030
113333
113636
113939
114242
114545
114848
115151
115454
115757
116060
A=1B=4points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
101217
011717
112020
112323
112626
102631
013131
113434
113737
114040
104045
014545
114848
115151
115454
105459
A=1B=5points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
111515
111818
112121
112424
112727
113030
113333
113636
113939
114242
114545
114848
115151
115454
115757
116060
A=1B=6points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
111515
111818
112121
112424
112727
113030
113333
113636
113939
114242
114545
114848
115151
115454
115757
116060
A=1B=7points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
111515
111818
112121
112424
112727
113030
113333
113636
113939
114242
114545
114848
115151
115454
115757
116060
A=2B=2points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
111515
111818
112121
112424
112727
113030
113333
113636
113939
114242
114545
114848
115151
115454
115757
116060
A=2B=3points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
111515
111818
112121
112424
112727
113030
113333
113636
113939
114242
114545
114848
115151
115454
115757
116060
A=2B=4points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
101217
111520
111823
112126
112429
102434
112737
113040
113343
113646
103651
113954
114257
114560
114863
104868
A=2B=5points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
111515
111818
112121
112424
112727
113030
113333
113636
113939
114242
114545
114848
115151
115454
115757
116060
A=2B=6points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
111515
111818
112121
112424
112727
113030
113333
113636
113939
114242
114545
114848
115151
115454
115757
116060
A=2B=7points
A
points
B
1005
1138
11611
11914
111217
111520
111823
112126
112429
112732
113035
113338
113641
113944
114247
114550
114853
115156
115459
115762
A=3B=3points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
001313
111616
111919
112222
112525
002626
112929
113232
113535
113838
003939
114242
114545
114848
115151
005252
A=3B=4points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
001313
101318
011818
112121
112424
002525
102530
013030
113333
113636
003737
103742
014242
114545
114848
004949
A=3B=5points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
001313
111616
111919
112222
112525
002626
112929
113232
113535
113838
003939
114242
114545
114848
115151
005252
A=3B=6points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
001313
111616
111919
112222
112525
002626
112929
113232
113535
113838
003939
114242
114545
114848
115151
005252
A=3B=7points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
001313
111616
111919
112222
112525
002626
112929
113232
113535
113838
003939
114242
114545
114848
115151
005252
A=4B=4points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
001313
001414
111717
112020
112323
002424
002525
112828
113131
113434
003535
003636
113939
114242
114545
004646
A=4B=5points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
001313
011813
112116
112419
112722
002823
013323
113626
113929
114232
004333
014833
115136
115439
115742
005843
A=4B=6points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
001313
011813
112116
112419
112722
002823
013323
113626
113929
114232
004333
014833
115136
115439
115742
005843
A=4B=7points
A
points
B
1005
0155
1188
111111
001212
011712
112015
112318
112621
002722
013222
113525
113828
114131
004232
014732
115035
115338
115641
005742
A=5B=5points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
111515
111818
112121
112424
112727
113030
113333
113636
113939
114242
114545
114848
115151
115454
115757
116060
A=5B=6points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
111515
111818
112121
112424
112727
113030
113333
113636
113939
114242
114545
114848
115151
115454
115757
116060
A=5B=7points
A
points
B
1133
1166
1199
111212
111515
111818
112121
112424
112727
113030
113333
113636
113939
114242
114545
114848
115151
115454
115757
116060
A=6B=6points
A
points
B
1133
0044
0055
0066
0077
0088
0099
001010
001111
001212
001313
001414
001515
001616
001717
001818
001919
002020
002121
002222
A=6B=7points
A
points
B
1133
0044
0055
0066
0077
0088
0099
001010
001111
001212
001313
001414
001515
001616
001717
001818
001919
002020
002121
002222
A=7B=7points
A
points
B
0150
01100
10105
101010
001111
001212
111515
111818
101823
112126
112429
102434
012934
013434
113737
114040
004141
004242
004343
114646
Classification after 224 games
1) Tit for TatFinal score=474
2) Tit for two TatFinal score=465
3) 1 mutant of Tit for Tat - TrdFinal score=429
4) Tit for Tat - RimFinal score=441
5) 1 mutant of Always cooperateFinal score=455
6) 7 mutant of Always defectFinal score=341
7) 3 mutant of RandomFinal score=390
Mutants of generation number 9
1) Tit for TatDNA=AAAAGAAAAATAUAG
2) Tit for two TatDNA=AATGATATTTTAUAG
3) 1 mutant of Tit for Tat - TrdDNA=ACCTACAATGACUAG
4) Tit for Tat - RimDNA=GTGGCGATTGTCUAG
5) 1 mutant of Always cooperateDNA=AAATACACATTGUAG
6) 7 mutant of Always defectDNA=TAATACTCTGAAUAG
7) 3 mutant of RandomDNA=GCTTACGCACCAUAG

Back to this article index

Back to release 2.0 index